Total newbie: would like a multi zone heating system, please advise

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Franco
    Automated Home Jr Member
    • Feb 2022
    • 10

    Total newbie: would like a multi zone heating system, please advise

    Good morning

    I have recently retired, and my heating requirements have somehow changed. I am in a three bed semidetached, with a Bosch/Worcester combi boiler (38Cdi). Which works great. This has been going with a Honeywell wall thermostat, which allows weekly schedules but not multi-zone (CM927)

    I would like to have all house on a fixed temperature, e.g. 18C. But during the day my lounge and study room at e.g. 23C, and at night only my bedroom at 23C.

    What do you advice to do? Already have individual radiator TRVs installed, but being a total novice, would need something fairly 8ntuitive to use, and with a quality installer in the Sheffield area.

    Any advice very welcome

    Franco
  • sxturbo
    Automated Home Jr Member
    • Apr 2022
    • 17

    #2
    Having seen the huge price increases on the Honeywell Evo home products I can no longer advise it. More so having had it installed for 2 years it's now giving me no end of trouble, and I seem to have entered into a major software glitch which no amount of factory resetting seems to fix.

    Honeywell are also slow and incumbent.

    If I don't all again I'm going for the Drayton wiser kit, very well priced and Drayton have been bringing regular updates to it

    Comment

    • toscal
      Moderator
      • Oct 2005
      • 2061

      #3
      hi Franco and welcome to the forums
      There are other options to consider. Shelly apart from offering a wide variety of WiFi enabled devices now offer a WiFi enabled TRV. . These could be added gradually as time and budget allows. Four of these valves could work out cheaper than 4 EVOhome valves.
      The Shelly valves use rechargeable batteries, so a mobile phone powerbank would be able to charge the valve in situ. In theory you wouldn't need anything else other than the valves, as a standard room thermostat could still be used to keep overall control. But temperature monitoring and control (of your boiler) is also possible using a Shelly 1 module with the temperature addon.
      Last edited by toscal; 24 April 2022, 04:51 PM.
      IF YOU CAN'T FIX IT WITH A HAMMER, YOU'VE GOT AN ELECTRICAL PROBLEM.
      Renovation Spain Blog

      Comment

      • Franco
        Automated Home Jr Member
        • Feb 2022
        • 10

        #4
        Thanks Toscal
        As I said, am a total newcomer to these concepts. Tell me if I have understood:

        I keep the existing thermostat, and set it at 24C. Then I turn all existing TRVs down to minimal settings, except the two wifi-enabled ones (one in bedroom and one in sitting rm). These will be activated by app on wifi, so that all the heat will be channelled on that single radiator at the right times. All other rooms in the while would be on minimal settings.

        Or did I get it wrong?

        Thanks
        Franco

        Comment

        • G4RHL
          Automated Home Legend
          • Jan 2015
          • 1580

          #5
          I have had Evohome for nearly 8 years. It works fine. The only issues were two. One was of my doing when I first set it up not reading the manual properly. The other was the DMW sensor losing contact from time to time, but ever at a time that deprived me of hot water. It is a known issue and I just ignored it. Now I have a combi boiler and now need for the DMW sensor. It is not really a complicate system. It works. Has done for the past 8 years. I am not sure about the others and I suspect all prices will be going up. If I was installing afresh I would still consider it

          Comment

          • CT1
            Automated Home Guru
            • Apr 2016
            • 189

            #6
            Had EvoHome for several years. EvoHome was the only system that provided full independent zone control. We had previously tried a combination of one room thermostat and radiator thermostats in each room (both simple and programmable TRVs) but this still resulted in rooms being too hot or too cold. EvoHome was far better. It can take time to get set up and programmed to your requirements and then works best if you just leave it alone. I would not class it as simple, other members of the household don’t want anything to do with setting any of the programmable features. We have ignored the things like weather compensation etc that came with the latest update and don’t let EvoHome start heating rooms in advance of the set time (optimisation). This keeps things simpler and easier for other members of the household to understand but does give the occasional temporary overshoot in temperature.

            If you can set it up and not need to make frequent changes, it usually requires nothing more than the occasional battery change and gives far better zone control and comfort levels than anything else we found. There currently appears to be a problem in buying devices. Hopefully this is just the general problem all manufacturers are having with component supply chains and not an indication that Resideo are thinking of withdrawing EvoHome.

            Comment

            • G4RHL
              Automated Home Legend
              • Jan 2015
              • 1580

              #7
              I concur, weather compensation and optimisation are unnecessary. Just set it up and don't keep playing with it!

              Comment

              • Franco
                Automated Home Jr Member
                • Feb 2022
                • 10

                #8
                Thanks
                Anybody in South Yorkshire can recommend an Evo installer? There avere some on the Honeywell Evo website, but have no idea who’s good. And no, I would not be able to do myself.
                Thanks for your advise
                Franco

                Comment

                • G4RHL
                  Automated Home Legend
                  • Jan 2015
                  • 1580

                  #9
                  Hopefully somebody here can make a recommendation for you. Those on the Honeywell site aren't all up to the task. I found the same with recommended Intergas installers. Honeywell may have selected proper qualified people now though. It is a while since I last checked. Years ago. I ended up doing it myself. It did not work, I called a recommended installer, I was advising him about the system. It did not work due to my mistake!

                  Comment

                  • Franco
                    Automated Home Jr Member
                    • Feb 2022
                    • 10

                    #10
                    In these cases, nothing is better than a recommendation from somebody local who had it installed - and was happy with the work.

                    Comment

                    • RedEarth
                      Automated Home Sr Member
                      • Jan 2021
                      • 71

                      #11
                      If you've currently got a Honeywell CM927 controlling your boiler then it's quite possible that it's paired with a BDR91 relay which is the same as what Evohome uses, so if that's the case then the installation may not be as complicated as you think it is, because you could re-use this relay with Evohome and therefore there would be no electrical work needed because you could just un-pair your CM927 from it and then pair the Evohome controller.

                      I was in the same position as you just over a year ago (OK, Vaillant combi instead of WB, 2-bed mid-terrace instead of 3-bed semi, and working from home due to the pandemic instead of retirement, but these are all insignificant details), I first swapped out the controllers so Evohome was initially working as a single zone, and I then added HR92's to each of the radiators and created zones for each one. It was fairly straightforward and the system has been working brilliantly ever since, specifically achieving the intended goal of only heating rooms as and when they're needed. As it happens I do use the optimisation and weather compensation features and I find they work well for me personally, but as others have said you can just turn them off if you want to keep things simple.

                      I'd certainly recommend Evohome to anyone, the only two slight drawbacks in my view are the current pricing/supply issues (all sorts of things going on in the world at the moment that might have caused this - chip shortages, staffing issues in the supply chain due to covid, ships getting wedged in the Suez Canal) and the Honeywell web API can be a bit ropey which means you might find that you can't use your mobile app/Alexa etc to control your heating, but none of this stops you being able to use the main controller to do anything it should be able to do so if you're upgrading from a basic single-zone wall controller then you're not losing anything you can currently do.

                      Comment

                      • Franco
                        Automated Home Jr Member
                        • Feb 2022
                        • 10

                        #12
                        Yes, it is a BDR91. (Left, mine; Right, Evo advert)

                        B338E789-8C18-4E06-ABA7-D7589C1E1B61.jpg 4FE99C80-A187-4882-9D43-DDFA8D0E481C.jpg

                        The Evo manual that I have seen online mentions BDR91A100. , is it the same?

                        Thanks
                        Franco
                        Last edited by Franco; 25 April 2022, 10:28 PM.

                        Comment

                        • G4RHL
                          Automated Home Legend
                          • Jan 2015
                          • 1580

                          #13
                          Much depends on the boiler you have but installing is not complex. Certainly not using OpenTherm with an Intergas combi. The latter is very much a simple DIY job

                          Comment

                          • CT1
                            Automated Home Guru
                            • Apr 2016
                            • 189

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Franco View Post
                            In these cases, nothing is better than a recommendation from somebody local who had it installed - and was happy with the work.
                            A good experienced installer can save a lot of teething problems. Unfortunately the forum has less activity in the summer months so you may have to wait longer for a recommendation. You could try and make a list of installers in your area then search for reviews of each of them.

                            Comment

                            • Franco
                              Automated Home Jr Member
                              • Feb 2022
                              • 10

                              #15
                              Thanks, done that, useless reviews.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X